Power Quality Management

POWER QUALITY

Power quality plays a key role to ensure reliable and trouble-free operation of various processes in the micro-processor dominated world of today and management of power quality has been included as an additional and essential duty of plant engineers. Many malfunctions & failures, so far remained unexplained, have now being attributed to power quality; or rather lack of it.

In order to understand power quality better, let's consider power received at consumer end as product that is manufactured at a power station and undergoes various processes of transformation that are comparable to damages occurring to a product that is mishandled.

Power quality, in its simplest form of definition, means the voltage & frequency are constant or have variance within permissible limits, and waveform are sinusoidal or have limited distortion and abnormalities are absent.

Power quality disturbances or abnormalities are inter-dependent; power quality is affected for factors internal as well as external.

External : the quality of power received from electric utility or source.

Electric Utility is required to supply power at pre-defined tolerances for voltage, frequency and waveform distortion. Factors that affect quality of power supplied by utility are poor line regulation, line faults, load swings, switching transients and other grid disturbances. The utility power abnormalities are represented in the following graphic.

Outage : Long term power interruption for 1 minute
Over voltage : Voltage exceeds its nominal value for 10 cycles
Under voltage : Voltage drops from its nominal value for 10 cycles
Voltage sag : Temporary drop of voltage for a few cycles
Spike, transient : A very sharp and short rise or fall in voltage or current
Surge, swell : Temporary voltage increase for 1 second to a few seconds usually associated with lightening strike

Internal : the quality of power affected by conditions within consumer's installation.

These include harmonic distortion resulting in malfunction of PQ sensitive equipments that cover a wide range. Installation of power electronic devices such as rectifiers, SMPS in workstations, UPS, Soft Starters, Dimmers in luminaries, Electric arc welders, etc. is directly responsible for generation of harmonics and consequent ill effects.

Other common causes of poor power quality within an installation are poor voltage regulation of transformer or generator, inappropriate installation practices of cabling, earthing, etc. leading to EMI and other effects.

It is interesting to note that power factor correction capacitors installed without de-tuning in a harmonic-rich environment could amplify harmonic levels, increase waveform distortion and are responsible for serious hazards such as harmonic resonance.

Frequency variance is very rarely observed phenomena and has the lowest tolerance values. Severe frequency variations could happen as a result of serious grid problems and are usually followed by widespread black outs that take hours to restore.

Internationally accepted standards for power quality

IEEE 519-1992 : Recommended Practices and Requirements for Harmonic Control in Electrical Power Systems at Point of Common Coupling or utility power entrance.
Restrictions on current and voltage harmonics are already maintained in many countries through IEEE 519-1992 in the USA and IEC 61000-3-2 / IEC 61000-3-4 in Europe.
These standards are associated with the popular and generally accepted idea of power quality.
These standards outline limitations on both voltage and current harmonics, in order to ensure that harmonic distortion levels throughout the entire electrical distribution system, from utility to consumer, will remain low enough for the system to function properly.
These limit the consumer in terms of how much harmonic current may be produced by the user's facility and limit the electric utility in terms of how much harmonic voltage distortion will be tolerated on the distribution system.

List of other IEEE PQ standards
IEEE P1547: Distributed Resources and Electric Power Systems Interconnection
IEEE SCC-22: Power Quality Standards Coordinating Committee
IEEE 1159:Monitoring Electric Power Quality
IEEE 1159.1: Guide For Recorder and Data Acquisition Requirements
IEEE 1159.2: Power Quality Event Characterization
IEEE 1159.3: Data File Format for Power Quality Data Interchange
IEEE P1564:Voltage Sag Indices
IEEE 1346:Power System Compatibility with Process Equipment
IEEE P1100: Power and Grounding Electronic Equipment (Emerald Book)
IEEE 1433: Power Quality Definitions
IEEE P1453: Voltage flicker
IEEE 519: Harmonic Control in Electrical Power Systems

IEEE Harmonics Working Group

  • Single-phase Harmonics Task Force
  • IEEE P519A Guide for Applying Harmonic Limits on Power Systems
  • Interharmonics Task Force
  • Harmonics Modeling and Simulation Task Force
  • Probabilistic Aspects of Harmonics Task Force
  • Surge Protective Devices Committee

IEEE P446: Emergency and standby power

IEEE P1409: Distribution Custom Power

Standards Acronyms
ANSI - American National Standards Institute
IEEE - Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers
IEC - International Electrotechnical Commission
NEMA - National Electrical Manufacturers Association
NFPA - National Fire Protection Association

FLICKER
Flicker may be defined as a specific voltage variance related to human perception and manifested in brightness of typical 60 watt incandescent lamp. The human perception of light flicker is often the limiting criteria for controlling small voltage fluctuations. The sensitivity is a function of the frequency of the fluctuations and it is also dependent on the voltage level of the lighting.

Flicker levels in IEC standards refer to Pst & Plt :

  • Pst is a value measured over 10 minutes that characterizes the likelihood that the voltage fluctuations would result in perceptible light flicker. A value of 1.0 is designed to represent the level that 50% of humans would perceive flicker in a 60 watt incandescent bulb.
  • Plt is derived from 2 hours of Pst values (12 values combined in cubic relationship).

IEC 61000-2-2 specifies flicker compatibility levels:

  • Short term flicker (Pst) : 1.0.
  • Long term flicker (Plt) : 0.8.

EN 50160 limit says 95% of the long term flicker values (Plt) should be less than 1.0 in one week measurement period.
Changes in the voltage, as commonly associated with motor starting inrush or switching a capacitor bank, are separated from the continuous flicker limits. IEC 61000-2-2 specifies a compatibility level of 3% for the individual voltage variations. EN 50160 specifies a limit of 5% for these variations but mentions that more significant variations (up to 10%) can occur for some switching events. Specific recommendations are not provided in IEEE but individual utilities usually have their own guidelines in the range 4-7%.

Harmonic distortion and mitigation techniques
Harmonic studies and mitigation techniques are a major task in power quality management, partly because these has been an established link between PQ issue & harmonics and secondly, harmonics mitigation reduces system losses; contributing to energy conservation.
Practically every commercial and industrial installation is infested with harmonics on account of growing use of power electronic devices such as UPS, inverters, soft starters, VFDs, fluorescent lighting, etc. Harmonic demand attention when system suffers PQ problems.


Building blocks of Harmonic mitigation

  • Harmonic analysis
  • Recording of harmonic levels in terms of THD, individual orders, severity of waveform distortion.
  • Possibility of harmonic resonance, system fault level.
  • Design of harmonic filter such as de-tuned, tuned or active.
  • Installation of harmonic filter and monitoring of reduced harmonic levels to desired values.
  • Compliance based on IEEE / EN / IEC standard

Energy Integra iffers integrated solutions in power quality management that cover PQ analysis, remedial measures, procurement assistance, post installation monitoring, etc.

 

Top